We introduce our system for thinking about the “structure/agency” or “systems and individuals” problem: how do the systems and structures of our lives shape us? How do we shape them? How free are we, and where are the places where more freedom is good, and the places where it might actually be bad? How do we confront the structural issues we face, or strengthen and preserve the good systems we do have in place?
Questions we’ll be asking
- How much can a system penalize an individual for not being part of it?
- How much can a system hurt an individual who is part of it?
- How much can a system benefit an individual that is part of it?
- How much can a system benefit an individual who is not part of it?
Our analytical axes
- Positive vs. Negative: is the relationship between systems and individuals good or bad—and if so, for society as a whole, for individuals, or both?
- Visible vs. Invisible: is the structural pressure visible or invisible—i.e., living in a capitalist society is invisible but deeply impacts us.
- Legal vs. Social: does the structure get its force through law and the power of the government, or through cultural and societal pressure?
- Organized vs. Unorganized: both social movements and legal structures may be more or less coherent and organized.
Applying the axes
Two big questions we’ll ask about the particulars for each issue we look at:
- How constrained are you by these structural pressures?
- To what extent is that constraint or freedom good or problematic?
We think that in almost no cases is a radical end of individual freedom or structural control right. Nor does any system have merely positive or negative outcomes; we live in a broken world where even the best systems working in the most productive cycles with the most virtuous individuals still cannot solve everything perfectly. (And, since people’s own situations and religious and ethical beliefs differe, there will be people who dispute our positive/negative valence. We make no apologies for ours, but we welcome disagreement!)
- “Equations”, by The Midnight Sons, which is Stephen. Used by Stephen’s permission. Or insistence, even.
- “Winning Slowly Theme” by Chris Krycho. Kind of strange to think it’s been two and a half years since he wrote this.
Many thanks to the people who help us make this show possible by their financial support! This month’s sponsors:
- Andrew Fallows
- Jeremy W. Sherman
- Jeremy Cherfas
If you’d like to support the show, you can make a pledge at Patreon or give directly via Square Cash.
We love to hear your thoughts. Hit us up via Twitter, Facebook, or email!